What Would Browns’ Super Bowl Odds Fade to if NFL’s Appeal of Suspension Is Successful?

What Would Browns' Super Bowl Odds Fade to if NFL's Appeal of Suspension Is Successful?

Deshaun Watson hands on waist at training camp

Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson, right, and offensive coordinator Alex Van Pelt watch from the sideline during the NFL football team’s football training camp in Berea on Monday.

Camp Watson 5

The NFL has appealed the 6-game suspension of Cleveland Browns’ quarterback Deshaun Watson
Watson is facing more than 24 pending lawsuits for sexual misconduct
See how an extended suspension could affect Cleveland’s title odds below

If you thought the Deshaun Watson saga was over once mediator Sue Robinson released her verdict, think again.

The NFL has chosen to appeal the 6-game suspension for Watson violating the NFL’s personal conduct policy. That may or may not affect the Cleveland Browns’ outlook for the coming season.

The worst-case scenario for Cleveland and the QB they signed to the richest guaranteed deal in history would be getting a suspension adjusted to a full season or longer along with a substantial fine and some form of treatment or education program he will have to complete.

The worst-case scenario for the NFL, and for optics in general, is if the NFL Players Association counters by suing the league. That case would take perhaps the course of the year to resolve, meaning Watson could essentially play from Week 1 and likely the whole season, as the legal system weaves through the case.

Watson is facing 24 separate lawsuits for sexual misconduct accusations. Speculation is that these trials will carry over into 2023. Watson is maintaining his innocence on all charges.

Below are the Browns’ future bets for the upcoming season. Should Watson in fact get the NFL’s upsize of discipline, let’s look at how these wagers could be affected.

Cleveland Browns Futures Odds

To Win Super Bowl
Odds
Buffalo Bills
+600
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
+750
Green Bay Packers
+1100
Kansas City Chiefs
+1100
Los Angeles Rams
+1200
Los Angeles Chargers
+1500
San Francisco 49ers
+1600
Denver Broncos
+1600
Dallas Cowboys
+2000
Cincinnati Bengals
+2200
Baltimore Ravens
+2200
Cleveland Browns
+2500
Indianapolis Colts
+2500
Philadelphia Eagles
+2800
Las Vegas Raiders
+3000
To Win AFC North Division
Odds
Baltimore Ravens
+155
Cincinnati Bengals
+180
Cleveland Browns
+300
Pittsburgh Steelers
+1000
Browns 2022-23 Win Total
Odds
8.5 Wins
Ov -110 / Un -110

*SB and Divison Odds from Aug 3 at Caesars Sportsbook; if you’re new to Caesars, be sure to claim the best Caesars Sportsbook promo when signing up. Win totals from FanDuel.

Cleveland’s Super Bowl odds didn’t move that much upon the appeal news. The figure peaked at +2200 once the suspension was handed out, and slid back to its current +2500.

The Browns also still remain with the third-best AFC North odds. They had +340 odds to win the division prior to the Watson trade back in March, and are still listed at +300 now. So those may not change drastically if the NFL wins the appeal. And their NFL win totals are set at a modest 8.5. Their win totals weren’t listed earlier this year, but you’d have to think no Deshaun would be worth at least a win or two of that total.

How Far Will Browns Fade?

The real odds jump occurred when the Browns acquired the 26-year-old in a trade with the Texans. At the time, the Browns jumped from +4000 Super Bowl odds all the way down to +1600, before the latest off-field headlines brought the odds to their current-2000s range.

If the NFL does in fact change the ruling to an indefinite suspension (which would carry at least a one-year ban), you have to expect the Browns’ Super Bowl odds to dip back to around that pre-Deshaun figure.

Over on ESPN, @AdamSchefter reported that Deshaun Watson: “Continues to insist that he’s done nothing wrong and has not shown remorse during this process and doesn’t believe he has to.”

That doesn’t mesh with the Browns ownership statement that Watson is “remorseful.” – He isn’t pic.twitter.com/YgxYf0wz9V

— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) August 3, 2022

Those odds would fit them perfectly in line with five other teams at +4000, who are all at varying degrees of satisfaction at their QB situation: the Patriots, Vikings, Raiders, Dolphins and Saints.

You could easily argue Mac Jones, Kirk Cousins, Derek Carr, Tua Tagovailoa and Jameis Winston are more preferable than anything Cleveland has left in the QB room (more on that below).

Despite sitting out all of last year as his legal troubles came to light, Watson is still considered to be one of the premier pivots in the NFL. Many believe he is capable of delivering a franchise the Lombardi Trophy.

That’s currently a short list of talents that include Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Justin Herbert and Lamar Jackson.

Deshaun Watson to Mike Harley Jr. #Browns pic.twitter.com/vTSnYsqrqM

— Camryn Justice (@camijustice) August 3, 2022

The last time Watson played was the 2020 year, where he made a third straight Pro Bowl despite Houston’s 4-12 record. He posted career highs in passing yards (4,823) and TD passes (33), and a career-low seven interceptions.

Claim Exclusive MLB and NFL Futures Bonuses With This Barstool Promo Code!

Cleveland’s Non-Watson Options

There is no plan B for the Browns. Especially now with Baker Mayfield in Carolina.

Even knowing Watson would face discipline — they structured his contract so his entire first year salary was paid out via signing bonus, ensuring he would keep as much as his $46 million annual salary as possible — they only managed to sign journeyman Jacoby Brissett.

Jacoby Brissett will now take over in Cleveland:

▪️ 7,742 passing yards
▪️ 653 rushing yards
▪️ 49 total TDs
▪️ 17 INTs pic.twitter.com/2JNvOPHmZ6

— B/R Gridiron (@brgridiron) August 1, 2022

The Browns also signed Josh Rosen, a 2018 first-round pick that hasn’t been able to make much of a mark in the league yet. No matter how talented the rest of Cleveland’s roster is (the Browns hold tight at 13 in SBD’s NFL Power Rankings), that QB duo isn’t instilling much confidence in any fan base.

Brissett does have two seasons where he’s started 15 games, but he’s only 11-19 in those starts, and 12-23 as a starter in his career.

The QB carousel doesn’t offer much variety now. Cam Newton is probably only name recognition at this point. Jimmy Garoppolo is on the trade block in San Francisco, but despite his winning pedigree (a 33-14 record as a starter), it’s safe to wonder if he’s been propped up by offensive wunderkid Kyle Shanahan in recent years.

Attn: #Browns, #Texans, #Steelers, #NYGiants, #Seahawks (am I missing any teams? 😂). This is video of Jimmy Garoppolo that was taken by fan @NitensonBrian today at #49ers training camp. pic.twitter.com/U3A9Zrlgzh

— Matt Maiocco (@MaioccoNBCS) August 3, 2022

Let’s put the Colin Kaepernick wishful thinking away here too. A QB-desperate team like Cleveland never took a flier on him despite their struggles at the position all these years. Now, considering  the PR hit bringing in Watson and his baggage and the how the situation has devolved, Kaepernick probably wants to avoid that situation more than the Browns steered clear of him.

If you do want to make a wager on Cleveland, keep close attention to Watson’s case. Should the league move the suspension for a year, that might trigger the NFLPA action, and could allow Watson a year’s reprieve. That would be worth a wager for the Browns, particularly for a division title and OVER the win total.

Author Image

Eric Rosales

NFL
NBA
Sports Writer & Editor

Sports Writer & Editor

Having worked in and around sports since 1997, Eric is truly a knowledgeable expert. The two-time journalism grad specializes in all things NBA and NFL. From TSN.ca to CTV’s Olympic Broadcast Consortium, Eric’s work has appeared in local and national publications alike.

NFL
NBA

Having worked in and around sports since 1997, Eric is truly a knowledgeable expert. The two-time journalism grad specializes in all things NBA and NFL. From TSN.ca to CTV’s Olympic Broadcast Consortium, Eric’s work has appeared in local and national publications alike.

Author: Jesse Smith